Ken Rosenthal claims the Braves are getting fed up with talks with the Padres over Jake Peavy.
The Braves are getting fed up.
After trying for more than a month to acquire Padres right-hander Jake Peavy, the team is beginning to explore other options, major-league sources say.
The Braves would still take Peavy, mind you. But they have informed the Padres that they could shift course rapidly once the free-agent market opens on Friday.
The Padres sent revised proposals to both the Braves and Dodgers yesterday and contrary to other rumors the Padres would be content to keep Jake Peavy if they don’t get a good enough offer. I don’t buy that considering the financial problems the Padres owner is in and the fact that they’re reportedly cutting payroll to about $40 million. I’m sure they’d be content to keep Peavy, but I don’t think they can, which is why Rosenthal said that neither the Cubs nor Braves would sweeten their offer. The Padres are screwed. They have to deal Peavy.
They’ve chosen to not offer Trevor Hoffman more than $4 million and are likely to lose him to free agency. Again, they have to deal Peavy.
Rosenthal implies that the Padres have a better offer, or are at least capable of putting together a better offer, which is of little surprise.
Then again, in the case of Peavy, the Padres might simply be waiting to the last possible moment to make the best possible deal.
The risk in that strategy is that it might cost them the players the Braves are willing to trade for Peavy — shortstop Yunel Escobar, either right-hander Charlie Morton or left-hander Jo Jo Reyes and either center fielder Gorkys Hernandez or Jordan Schaefer.
The Cubs might be offering a more established pitcher, left-hander Sean Marshall and perhaps a top prospect of their own, Class A third baseman Josh Vitters. But Escobar likely is the best player in either team’s proposal, and the Cubs cannot give the Padres a center fielder as promising as Hernandez or Schaefer.
Still, the Padres obviously are intrigued by the Cubs’ package; otherwise, they already would have traded Peavy to the Braves.
If the Cubs are willing to include Josh Vitters in the deal I just don’t see how the Braves offer is better. Morton and Reyes are number 5 starters. If the Padres want a number 5 starter how about they take Jason Marquis from the Cubs? Gorkys Hernandez has a ton of potential, but that’s all it is. He’s very young, but only hit for a .735 OPS in High A. Felix Pie was a far superior prospect and probably still is a better prospect with a greater chance of succeeding at the big league level. Jordan Schaefer is a pretty good prospect though and it’s one that would likely trump Josh Vitters.
All we really know right now is that the Padres are saying they don’t have to trade Peavy and that they have sent revised proposals to the Cubs and Braves. It appears, according to Rosenthal, that neither team will blink knowing that the Padres do in fact have to trade Jake Peavy.
I figure the Padres have 2 choices: trade Peavy before the end of the week (before free agency begins) or wait until late December or later to trade him.
The Cubs offer to Dempster is supposedly about the same as the 4/41 deal the Cardinals gave to Kyle Lohse.
Sources indicate that the Cubs’ four-year offer to free-agent right-hander Ryan Dempster is in the range of Kyle Lohse’s new $41 million deal with the Cardinals. Dempster surely would prefer to exceed Carlos Silva’s $48 million free-agent contract with the Mariners last offseason, but most executives consider that deal an aberration — read: mistake. Dempster, 31, pitched more than 200 innings last season for the first time since 2002, raising concerns about whether he can sustain such a workload. Still, teams such as the Braves and Blue Jays surely will consider him attractive
Yeah, he’d get a lot better offer if he waits awhile. Probably not from the Cubs, but from another team anyway.


1. ccd (view all comments) — Nov 11, 2008 @ 10:42 AM
hopefully this whole thing is playing right into Jim Hendry’s hand.